docker API接口service update错误记录 error while removing network:…

一、问题 error while removing network:…

创建srvice的参数的时候，如果设置了network参数（接口POST：service/create）

[{
  "Image": "nginx",
  "ImageVersion": "1.17",
  "ServiceName": "test-chow",
  "Replicas": 3,
  "Command": [],
  "ContainerEnv": [],
  "PortConfig": [
    {
      "Protocol": "tcp",
      "TargetPort": 80,
      "PublishedPort": 8081
    }
  ],
  "Networks": [
    {
      "Target": "chow",
      "Aliases": null,
      "DriverOpts": null
    }
  ],
  "UpdateConfig": {
    "Parallelism": 1,
    "Delay": 10000000000,
    "FailureAction": "",
    "Monitor": null,
    "MaxFailureRatio": 0,
    "Order": null
  },
  "RollbackConfig": {
    "Parallelism": null,
    "Delay": null,
    "FailureAction": null,
    "Monitor": null,
    "MaxFailureRatio": 0,
    "Order": ""
  },
  "RestartPolicy": {
    "Condition": null,
    "Delay": null,
    "MaxAttempts": null
  },
  "WarehouseUrl": null,
  "WarehousePwd": null,
  "WarehouseUserName": null,
  "Mount": []
}]

而更新的时候，没有传network参数，会报错：error while removing network:…

更新service参数如下:（接口PUT：/service/update）

{
  "ServiceId": "itnl2vrkixib9hlgtmsuj4awu",
  "Image": "nginx",
  "ImageVersion": "1.17",
  "ServiceName": "test-chow",
  "Replicas": 2
}

同时，因为端口等其他参数也没传，造成更新之后，端口啥的都消失了，截图如下：

1. 创建service的时候

2. 更新service之后

 

 二、分析错误原因

先不考虑端口等其他问题，先分析造成network错误的原因，上面是创建service的时候设置了network参数，下面对应几个更新service的时候传不同参数的结果

1. 更新的时候 network不变，相当于不更改network，（更改了副本数）

（1）只传部分参数，报错

{ // 更新的时候传的参数
  "ServiceId": "9t2jucsc3t1i0t9bx2n7csmjf",
  "Image": "nginx",
  "ImageVersion": "1.17",
  "ServiceName": "test-chow",
  "Replicas": 2,
  "Networks": [
    {
      "Target": "chow",
      "Aliases": null,
      "DriverOpts": null
    }
  ]
}

（2）、全量传参，不报错

{
  "ServiceId": "i8cdkcbb4o9ly0nczqlgt5l3l",
  "Image": "nginx",
  "ImageVersion": "1.17",
  "ServiceName": "test-chow",
  "Replicas": 2,
  "Command": [],
  "ContainerEnv": [],
  "PortConfig": [
    {
      "Protocol": "tcp",
      "TargetPort": 80,
      "PublishedPort": 8082
    }
  ],
  "Networks": [
    {
      "Target": "chow",
      "Aliases": null,
      "DriverOpts": null
    }
  ],
  "UpdateConfig": {
    "Parallelism": 1,
    "Delay": 10000000000,
    "FailureAction": "",
    "Monitor": null,
    "MaxFailureRatio": 0,
    "Order": null
  },
  "RollbackConfig": {
    "Parallelism": null,
    "Delay": 10000000000,
    "FailureAction": null,
    "Monitor": null,
    "MaxFailureRatio": 0,
    "Order": ""
  },
  "RestartPolicy": {
    "Condition": null,
    "Delay": null,
    "MaxAttempts": null
  },
  "WarehouseUrl": null,
  "WarehousePwd": null,
  "WarehouseUserName": null,
  "Mount": []
}

2. 更新的时候，不传network参数，相当于移除network

（1）部分传参，报错

{
  "ServiceId": "tx8882z81lh834uenw4tcgt48",
  "Image": "nginx",
  "ImageVersion": "1.17",
  "ServiceName": "test-chow",
  "Replicas": 2
}

（2）全量传参，不报错（参数太多，博客省略部分，实际传参的时候有）

{
  "ServiceId": "uvknv24zb8q2iouoz9lv5v13n",
  "Image": "nginx",
  "ImageVersion": "1.17",
  "ServiceName": "test-chow",
  "Replicas": 2,
  "Command": [],
  "ContainerEnv": [],
  "PortConfig": [
    {
      "Protocol": "tcp",
      "TargetPort": 80,
      "PublishedPort": 8082
    }
  ],
  ....省略
}

3. 更新的时候，传network，但是是添加network

（1）部分传参，报错

{
  "ServiceId": "aqp2b7cmrh5egjezenuf0vx6r",
  "Image": "nginx",
  "ImageVersion": "1.17",
  "ServiceName": "test-chow",
  "Replicas": 2,
  "Networks": [
    {
      "Target": "chow",
      "Aliases": null,
      "DriverOpts": null
    },
    {
      "Target": "my-net",
      "Aliases": null,
      "DriverOpts": null
    }
  ]
}

（2）全量传参，不报错

{
  "ServiceId": "bn0k9vxspi98m8qz9ceh14jc1",
  "Image": "nginx",
  "ImageVersion": "1.17",
  "ServiceName": "test-chow",
  "Replicas": 2,
  "Command": [],
  "ContainerEnv": [],
  "PortConfig": [
    {
      "Protocol": "tcp",
      "TargetPort": 80,
      "PublishedPort": 8082
    }
  ],
  "Networks": [
    {
      "Target": "chow",
      "Aliases": null,
      "DriverOpts": null
    },
    {
      "Target": "my-net",
      "Aliases": null,
      "DriverOpts": null
    }
  ],
  ...省略
}

4. 更新的时候，传network，但是是移除一个network

（1）部分传参，报错

{
  "ServiceId": "5k0nt8l45nbycxpzb0o5gzy38",
  "Image": "nginx",
  "ImageVersion": "1.17",
  "ServiceName": "test-chow",
  "Replicas": 2,
  "Networks": [
    {
      "Target": "chow",
      "Aliases": null,
      "DriverOpts": null
    }
  ]
}

（2）全量传参，不报错

{
  "ServiceId": "21ixmxc0xvh4s0t2jr1ke1ofl",
  "Image": "nginx",
  "ImageVersion": "1.17",
  "ServiceName": "test-chow",
  "Replicas": 2,
  "Command": [],
  "ContainerEnv": [],
  "PortConfig": [
    {
      "Protocol": "tcp",
      "TargetPort": 80,
      "PublishedPort": 8082
    }
  ],
  "Networks": [
    {
      "Target": "chow",
      "Aliases": null,
      "DriverOpts": null
    }
  ],
  ...省略
}

总结以上发现，只要是只传部分参数，就会报错，但我又不能每次更新都让调用接口的人把所有的参数传过来，怎么办呢？

 大量测试，从全量传参一个一个减少参数，看看到底是哪个参数不传造成的，经过测试发现必须要穿更新配置参数UpdateConfig，并且Parallelism参数（同时更新数）必须设置为1（个人猜测是docker service异步更新造成的？）

{
  "ServiceId": "ldpoqhv2yufff7i7ulqutii9c",
  "Image": "nginx",
  "ImageVersion": "1.17",
  "ServiceName": "test-chow",
  "Replicas": 2,
  "Networks": [
    {
      "Target": "chow",
      "Aliases": null,
      "DriverOpts": null
    }
  ],
  "UpdateConfig": {
    "Parallelism": 1,
    "Delay": 10000000000,
    "FailureAction": "",
    "Monitor": null,
    "MaxFailureRatio": 0,
    "Order": null
  }
}

既然找到原因了，那么设置成这个参数为非空必传就行了，但是有个问题，每次都要取查询上次的这个参数，比较麻烦，个人解决方案是再程序内部判断接口是否传这个参数

如果接口没传这个参数，内部逻辑代码是主动去查，用查到的填充

如果接口传了这个参数，内部逻辑代码是主动去查，用查到的数据判断有没有network配置，如果有network配置，再去判断传的参数是否设置Parallelism为1，如果不是，提醒接口调用者

 

最后又做了不等service 的副本容器启动起来，立即更新srvice，报错

 

 

5. 创建的时候，不全两传参且不设置network，更新的时候，完全没问题，即使更新的时候不穿UpdateConfig参数

service/create

[{
  "Image": "nginx",
  "ImageVersion": "1.17",
  "ServiceName": "test-chow",
  "Replicas": 3
}]

service/update

{
  "ServiceId": "vi7y48jxaj05h2w0vjnpb3oi0",
  "Image": "nginx",
  "ImageVersion": "1.17",
  "ServiceName": "test-chow",
  "Replicas": 2
}

6. 创建service的时候不全传，但参设置network，不设置UpdateConfig

1. 更新的时候不传network和UpdateConfig，报错

创建参数：

[{
  "Image": "nginx",
  "ImageVersion": "1.17",
  "ServiceName": "test-chow",
  "Replicas": 3,
  "Networks": [
    {
      "Target": "chow",
      "Aliases": null,
      "DriverOpts": null
    },
    {
      "Target": "my-net",
      "Aliases": null,
      "DriverOpts": null
    }
  ]
}]

更新参数：

{
  "ServiceId": "t7f637mq0e3cpczdtrrjm72kf",
  "Image": "nginx",
  "ImageVersion": "1.17",
  "ServiceName": "test-chow",
  "Replicas": 2
}

2. 更新的时候不传network，传UpdateConfig，不报错

创建参数：

[{
  "Image": "nginx",
  "ImageVersion": "1.17",
  "ServiceName": "test-chow",
  "Replicas": 3,
  "Networks": [
    {
      "Target": "chow",
      "Aliases": null,
      "DriverOpts": null
    },
    {
      "Target": "my-net",
      "Aliases": null,
      "DriverOpts": null
    }
  ]
}]

更新参数：

{
  "ServiceId": "6vlve54skeq2odj5py4aign3f",
  "Image": "nginx",
  "ImageVersion": "1.17",
  "ServiceName": "test-chow",
  "Replicas": 2,
  "UpdateConfig": {
    "Parallelism": 1,
    "Delay": 10000000000,
    "FailureAction": "",
    "Monitor": null,
    "MaxFailureRatio": 0,
    "Order": null
  }
}

三、结论：

经过测试（没有大量测试），目前发现的是

如果创建service的时候设置network，那么更新service的时候需要传参UpdateConfig参数

如果创建service的时候不设置network，那么更新service的时候，可以不穿UpdateConfig参数