c# sqlsugar,hisql,freesql orm框架全方位性能测试对比 sqlserver 性能测试
在2022年1月份本人做过一次sqlsugar,hisql,freesql三个框架的性能测试，上次主要是测的sqlserver下的常规插入（非bulkcopy的方式数据插入）,hisql与目前比较流行的ORM框架性能测试对比 时间已经过半年，这次我就测的更完整点测试方案如下
2022.6.23 修改
发了此篇测试后受到了某知名ORM作者的威胁
再次声明本测试是基于我的电脑环境多次测试的结果，已经开放了测试源代码 ，不针对于任何ORM品牌， 后期将会对Dapper和efcore测试
删贴？ 那是不可能的，有测试源码 快与慢大家自己评定
如果开源框架不能接受别人的测试 那么最好闭源。而不是叫人删贴
测试方案
- 测试四种数据库（sqlserver,mysql,oralce,postgresql) 每种数据库写一遍测试文章
- 常规插入和批量插入
- 数据量从5条到100W间的数据插入
- 数据列从5列和50列的各种数据类型场景
- 开源测试代码供各位网友查看审核是否测试公平公正
测试源码https://github.com/tansar/HiSqlTestDemo
测试环境
操作系统环境
sqlserver 环境
mysql 环境
oracle 环境
postgresql 环境
sqlserver 常规数据插入测试
10列以下字段测试代码如下
public static void TestSqlServerInsert(int _count)
{
//hisql连接 请先配置好数据库连接
HiSqlClient sqlClient = Demo_Init.GetSqlClient();
//hisql需要初始货安装 只需要执行一次
sqlClient.CodeFirst.InstallHisql();
//freesql连接
IFreeSql freeClient = Demo_Init.GetFreeSqlClient();
//sqlsugar连接
SqlSugarClient sugarClient = Demo_Init.GetSugarClient();
sqlClient.CodeFirst.CreateTable(typeof(Table.HTest01));
Console.WriteLine("初始化hisql专用表成功!");
sqlClient.CodeFirst.CreateTable(typeof(Table.HTest02));
Console.WriteLine("初始化sqlsugar专用表成功!");
sqlClient.CodeFirst.CreateTable(typeof(Table.HTest03));
Console.WriteLine("初始化freesql专用表成功!");
Console.WriteLine($"测试场景 Sqlserver 向表中插入{_count}条数据 常规数据插入)");
Console.WriteLine($"用常规数据插入最适应日常应用场景");
List<object> lstobj = new List<object>();
List<Table.HTest02> lstobj2 = new List<Table.HTest02>();
List<Table.HTest03> lstobj3 = new List<Table.HTest03>();
Random random = new Random();
//插入的参数值都随机产生 以免数据库执行相同SQL时会有缓存影响测试结果
for (int i = 0; i < _count; i++)
{
//hisql可以用实体类也可以用匿名类
lstobj.Add(new Table.HTest01 { SID = (i + 1), UName = $"hisql{i}", Age = 20 + (i % 50), Salary = 5000 + (i % 2000) + random.Next(10), Descript = $"hisql初始创建" });
//sqlsugar用匿句类报错用实体类
lstobj2.Add(new Table.HTest02 { SID = (i + 1), UName = $"sqlsugar{i}", Age = 20 + (i % 50), Salary = 5000 + (i % 2000) + random.Next(10), Descript = $"sqlsugar初始创建" });
lstobj3.Add(new Table.HTest03 { SID = (i + 1), UName = $"freesql{i}", Age = 20 + (i % 50), Salary = 5000 + (i % 2000) + random.Next(10), Descript = $"freesql初始创建" });
}
//删除测试表中的数据
sqlClient.TrunCate("HTest01").ExecCommand();
sqlClient.TrunCate("HTest02").ExecCommand();
sqlClient.TrunCate("HTest03").ExecCommand();
Stopwatch sw = new Stopwatch();
#region freesql
sw.Reset();
Console.WriteLine("------------------------------");
Console.WriteLine("----------FreeSql 测试----------");
Console.WriteLine($"FreeSql 预热...{DateTime.Now.ToString("yyyy-MM-dd HH:mm:ss.fff")}");
var temp3 = freeClient.Queryable<Table.HTest03>().Where(w => w.Age < 0).ToList();
Console.WriteLine($"FreeSql 正在插入数据\t{DateTime.Now.ToString("yyyy-MM-dd HH:mm:ss.fff")}");
sw.Start();
freeClient.Insert<Table.HTest03>(lstobj3).ExecuteAffrows();
sw.Stop();
Console.WriteLine($"FreeSql 数据插入{_count}条 耗时{sw.Elapsed}秒");
sw.Reset();
#endregion
#region hisql
sw.Reset();
Console.WriteLine("------------------------------");
Console.WriteLine("----------HiSql 测试----------");
Console.WriteLine($"HiSql 预热...{DateTime.Now.ToString("yyyy-MM-dd HH:mm:ss.fff")}");
var temp1 = sqlClient.Query("HTest01").Field("*").Take(1).Skip(1).ToDynamic();
Console.WriteLine($"HiSql 正在插入数据\t{DateTime.Now.ToString("yyyy-MM-dd HH:mm:ss.fff")}");
sw.Start();
sqlClient.Insert("HTest01", lstobj).ExecCommand();
sw.Stop();
Console.WriteLine($"hisql 数据插入{_count}条 耗时{sw.Elapsed}秒");
sw.Reset();
#endregion
50列字段测试代码如下
public static void TestSqlServer50ColInsert(int _count)
{
//hisql连接 请先配置好数据库连接
HiSqlClient sqlClient = Demo_Init.GetSqlClient();
//hisql需要初始货安装 只需要执行一次
sqlClient.CodeFirst.InstallHisql();
//freesql连接
IFreeSql freeClient = Demo_Init.GetFreeSqlClient();
//sqlsugar连接
SqlSugarClient sugarClient = Demo_Init.GetSugarClient();
sqlClient.CodeFirst.CreateTable(typeof(Table.H_Test50C01));
Console.WriteLine("初始化hisql专用表成功!");
sqlClient.CodeFirst.CreateTable(typeof(Table.H_Test50C02));
Console.WriteLine("初始化sqlsugar专用表成功!");
sqlClient.CodeFirst.CreateTable(typeof(Table.H_Test50C03));
Console.WriteLine("初始化freesql专用表成功!");
Console.WriteLine($"测试场景 Sqlserver 向表中插入{_count}条数据 50列 常规数据插入)");
Console.WriteLine($"用常规数据插入最适应日常应用场景");
List<object> lstobj = new List<object>();
List<Table.H_Test50C02> lstobj2 = new List<Table.H_Test50C02>();
List<Table.H_Test50C03> lstobj3 = new List<Table.H_Test50C03>();
Random random = new Random();
//插入的参数值都随机产生 以免数据库执行相同SQL时会有缓存影响测试结果
for (int i = 0; i < _count; i++)
{
//hisql可以用实体类也可以用匿名类
lstobj.Add(new Table.H_Test50C01 {
Material=(900000+i).ToString(),
Batch=(30000000+i).ToString(),
TestNum1= random.Next(10,100),
TestNum2 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum3 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum4 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum5 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum6 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum7 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum8 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum9 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum10 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum11 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum12 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum13= random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum14= random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum15= random.Next(10, 100),
TestStr1 = $"hisql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr2 = $"hisql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr3 = $"hisql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr4 = $"hisql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr5 = $"hisql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr6 = $"hisql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr7 = $"hisql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr8 = $"hisql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr9 = $"hisql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr10 = $"hisql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr11 = $"hisql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr12 = $"hisql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr13 = $"hisql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr14 = $"hisql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr15 = $"hisql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestDec1 = i+ random.Next(1, 10000)/3,
TestDec2 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec3 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec4 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec5 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec6 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec7 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec8 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec9 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec10 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec11 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec12 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec13 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec14 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec15 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
Salary = 5000 + (i % 2000) + random.Next(10), Descript = $"hisql初始创建" });
//sqlsugar用匿句类报错用实体类
lstobj2.Add(new Table.H_Test50C02
{
Material = (900000 + i).ToString(),
Batch = (30000000 + i).ToString(),
TestNum1 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum2 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum3 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum4 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum5 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum6 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum7 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum8 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum9 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum10 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum11 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum12 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum13 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum14 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum15 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestStr1 = $"sqlsugar{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr2 = $"sqlsugar{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr3 = $"sqlsugar{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr4 = $"sqlsugar{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr5 = $"sqlsugar{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr6 = $"sqlsugar{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr7 = $"sqlsugar{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr8 = $"sqlsugar{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr9 = $"sqlsugar{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr10 = $"sqlsugar{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr11 = $"sqlsugar{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr12 = $"sqlsugar{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr13 = $"sqlsugar{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr14 = $"sqlsugar{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr15 = $"sqlsugar{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestDec1 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec2 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec3 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec4 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec5 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec6 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec7 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec8 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec9 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec10 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec11 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec12 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec13 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec14 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec15 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
Salary = 5000 + (i % 2000) + random.Next(10),
Descript = $"sqlsugar初始创建"
});
lstobj3.Add(new Table.H_Test50C03
{
Material = (900000 + i).ToString(),
Batch = (30000000 + i).ToString(),
TestNum1 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum2 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum3 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum4 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum5 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum6 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum7 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum8 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum9 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum10 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum11 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum12 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum13 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum14 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum15 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestStr1 = $"freesql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr2 = $"freesql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr3 = $"freesql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr4 = $"freesql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr5 = $"freesql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr6 = $"freesql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr7 = $"freesql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr8 = $"freesql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr9 = $"freesql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr10 = $"freesql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr11 = $"freesql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr12 = $"freesql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr13 = $"freesql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr14 = $"freesql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr15 = $"freesql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestDec1 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec2 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec3 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec4 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec5 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec6 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec7 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec8 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec9 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec10 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec11 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec12 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec13 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec14 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec15 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
Salary = 5000 + (i % 2000) + random.Next(10),
Descript = $"freesql初始创建"
});
}
//删除测试表中的数据
sqlClient.TrunCate("H_Test50C01").ExecCommand();
sqlClient.TrunCate("H_Test50C02").ExecCommand();
sqlClient.TrunCate("H_Test50C03").ExecCommand();
Stopwatch sw = new Stopwatch();
#region freesql
sw.Reset();
Console.WriteLine("------------------------------");
Console.WriteLine("----------FreeSql 测试----------");
Console.WriteLine($"FreeSql 预热...{DateTime.Now.ToString("yyyy-MM-dd HH:mm:ss.fff")}");
var temp3 = freeClient.Queryable<Table.H_Test50C03>().Where(w => w.TestDec1 < 0).ToList();
Console.WriteLine($"FreeSql 正在插入数据\t{DateTime.Now.ToString("yyyy-MM-dd HH:mm:ss.fff")}");
sw.Start();
freeClient.Insert<Table.H_Test50C03>(lstobj3).ExecuteAffrows();
sw.Stop();
Console.WriteLine($"FreeSql 数据插入{_count}条 耗时{sw.Elapsed}秒");
sw.Reset();
#endregion
#region hisql
sw.Reset();
Console.WriteLine("------------------------------");
Console.WriteLine("----------HiSql 测试----------");
Console.WriteLine($"HiSql 预热...{DateTime.Now.ToString("yyyy-MM-dd HH:mm:ss.fff")}");
var temp1 = sqlClient.Query("H_Test50C01").Field("*").Take(1).Skip(1).ToDynamic();
Console.WriteLine($"HiSql 正在插入数据\t{DateTime.Now.ToString("yyyy-MM-dd HH:mm:ss.fff")}");
sw.Start();
sqlClient.Insert("H_Test50C01", lstobj).ExecCommand();
sw.Stop();
Console.WriteLine($"hisql 数据插入{_count}条 耗时{sw.Elapsed}秒");
sw.Reset();
#endregion
#region sqlsugar
sw.Reset();
Console.WriteLine("------------------------------");
Console.WriteLine("----------SqlSugar 测试----------");
Console.WriteLine($"SqlSugar 预热...{DateTime.Now.ToString("yyyy-MM-dd HH:mm:ss.fff")}");
var temp2 = sugarClient.Queryable<Table.H_Test50C03>("H_Test50C03").Where(w => w.TestDec1 < 1).ToList();
Console.WriteLine($"sqlsugar 正在插入数据\t{DateTime.Now.ToString("yyyy-MM-dd HH:mm:ss.fff")}");
sw.Start();
sugarClient.Insertable(lstobj2).AS("H_Test50C03").ExecuteCommand();
sw.Stop();
Console.WriteLine($"sqlsugar 数据插入{_count}条 耗时{sw.Elapsed}秒");
sw.Reset();
#endregion
}
测试结果
5条记录10列以下测试结果截图
5条记录50列测试结果截图
50条记录10列以下测试结果截图
50条记录50列测试结果截图
100条记录10列以下测试结果截图
100条记录50列测试结果截图
500条记录10列以下测试结果截图
500条记录50列测试结果截图
1000条记录10列以下测试结果截图
1000条记录50列测试结果截图
5000条记录10列以下测试结果截图
5000条记录50列测试结果截图
10000条记录10列以下测试结果截图
10000条记录50列测就结果截图
50000条记录10列以下测试结果截图
50000条记录50列测试结果截图
100000条记录10列以下测试结果截图
100000条记录50列测试结果截图
sqlsugar 在执行此操作时抛出异常
错误提示：System.Data.SqlClient.SqlException:“资源池“default”没有足够的系统内存来运行此查询
在单独只执行sqlsugar的测试样例依然报此错误 通过分析sqlsugar的底层执行逻辑是因为它把所有的插入都拼成了一个插入sql文档造成的
测试结果
sqlserver 批量（bulkcopy）数据插入测试
可能会有很多人认为如果大批量数据插入肯定不会用常规的方式插入应该用BulkCopy的方式插入，好，那么我们再来测测基于数据库厂商提供的SDK驱动自带的BulkCopy再来对比一下三个框架的性能
10列以下批量插入的bulkcopy测试代码
public static void TestSqlServerBulkCopy(int _count)
{
//hisql连接 请先配置好数据库连接
HiSqlClient sqlClient = Demo_Init.GetSqlClient();
//hisql需要初始货安装 只需要执行一次
sqlClient.CodeFirst.InstallHisql();
//freesql连接
IFreeSql freeClient = Demo_Init.GetFreeSqlClient();
//sqlsugar连接
SqlSugarClient sugarClient = Demo_Init.GetSugarClient();
sqlClient.CodeFirst.CreateTable(typeof(Table.HTest01));
Console.WriteLine("初始化hisql专用表成功!");
sqlClient.CodeFirst.CreateTable(typeof(Table.HTest02));
Console.WriteLine("初始化sqlsugar专用表成功!");
sqlClient.CodeFirst.CreateTable(typeof(Table.HTest03));
Console.WriteLine("初始化freesql专用表成功!");
Console.WriteLine($"测试场景 Sqlserver 向表中插入{_count}条数据 BulkCopy方式插入");
Console.WriteLine($"适用于大量数据导入场景");
List<object> lstobj = new List<object>();
List<Table.HTest02> lstobj2 = new List<Table.HTest02>();
List<Table.HTest03> lstobj3 = new List<Table.HTest03>();
Random random = new Random();
//插入的参数值都随机产生 以免数据库执行相同SQL时会有缓存影响测试结果
for (int i = 0; i < _count; i++)
{
//hisql可以用实体类也可以用匿名类
lstobj.Add(new Table.HTest01 { SID = (i + 1), UName = $"hisql{i}", Age = 20 + (i % 50), Salary = 5000 + (i % 2000) + random.Next(10), Descript = $"hisql初始创建" });
//sqlsugar用匿句类报错用实体类
lstobj2.Add(new Table.HTest02 { SID = (i + 1), UName = $"sqlsugar{i}", Age = 20 + (i % 50), Salary = 5000 + (i % 2000) + random.Next(10), Descript = $"sqlsugar初始创建" });
lstobj3.Add(new Table.HTest03 { SID = (i + 1), UName = $"freesql{i}", Age = 20 + (i % 50), Salary = 5000 + (i % 2000) + random.Next(10), Descript = $"freesql初始创建" });
}
//删除测试表中的数据
sqlClient.TrunCate("HTest01").ExecCommand();
sqlClient.TrunCate("HTest02").ExecCommand();
sqlClient.TrunCate("HTest03").ExecCommand();
Stopwatch sw = new Stopwatch();
#region freesql
sw.Reset();
Console.WriteLine("------------------------------");
Console.WriteLine("----------FreeSql 测试----------");
Console.WriteLine($"FreeSql 预热...{DateTime.Now.ToString("yyyy-MM-dd HH:mm:ss.fff")}");
var temp3 = freeClient.Queryable<Table.HTest03>().Where(w => w.Age < 0).ToList();
Console.WriteLine($"FreeSql 正在插入数据\t{DateTime.Now.ToString("yyyy-MM-dd HH:mm:ss.fff")}");
sw.Start();
//freeClient.Insert<Table.HTest03>(lstobj3).ExecuteAffrows();
freeClient.Insert<Table.HTest03>(lstobj3).ExecuteSqlBulkCopy();
sw.Stop();
Console.WriteLine($"FreeSql 数据插入{_count}条 耗时{sw.Elapsed}秒");
sw.Reset();
#endregion
#region hisql
sw.Reset();
Console.WriteLine("------------------------------");
Console.WriteLine("----------HiSql 测试----------");
Console.WriteLine($"HiSql 预热...{DateTime.Now.ToString("yyyy-MM-dd HH:mm:ss.fff")}");
var temp1 = sqlClient.Query("HTest01").Field("*").Take(1).Skip(1).ToDynamic();
Console.WriteLine($"HiSql 正在插入数据\t{DateTime.Now.ToString("yyyy-MM-dd HH:mm:ss.fff")}");
sw.Start();
//sqlClient.Insert("HTest01", lstobj).ExecCommand();
sqlClient.BulkCopyExecCommand("HTest01", lstobj);
sw.Stop();
Console.WriteLine($"hisql 数据插入{_count}条 耗时{sw.Elapsed}秒");
sw.Reset();
#endregion
#region sqlsugar
sw.Reset();
Console.WriteLine("------------------------------");
Console.WriteLine("----------SqlSugar 测试----------");
Console.WriteLine($"SqlSugar 预热...{DateTime.Now.ToString("yyyy-MM-dd HH:mm:ss.fff")}");
var temp2 = sugarClient.Queryable<Table.HTest02>("HTest02").Where(w => w.Age < 1).ToList();
Console.WriteLine($"sqlsugar 正在插入数据\t{DateTime.Now.ToString("yyyy-MM-dd HH:mm:ss.fff")}");
sw.Start();
//sugarClient.Insertable(lstobj2).AS("HTest02").ExecuteCommand();
sugarClient.Fastest<Table.HTest02>().BulkCopy(lstobj2);
sw.Stop();
Console.WriteLine($"sqlsugar 数据插入{_count}条 耗时{sw.Elapsed}秒");
sw.Reset();
#endregion
}
50列批量插入的bulkcopy测试代码
public static void TestSqlServer50ColInsert(int _count)
{
//hisql连接 请先配置好数据库连接
HiSqlClient sqlClient = Demo_Init.GetSqlClient();
//hisql需要初始货安装 只需要执行一次
sqlClient.CodeFirst.InstallHisql();
//freesql连接
IFreeSql freeClient = Demo_Init.GetFreeSqlClient();
//sqlsugar连接
SqlSugarClient sugarClient = Demo_Init.GetSugarClient();
sqlClient.CodeFirst.CreateTable(typeof(Table.H_Test50C01));
Console.WriteLine("初始化hisql专用表成功!");
sqlClient.CodeFirst.CreateTable(typeof(Table.H_Test50C02));
Console.WriteLine("初始化sqlsugar专用表成功!");
sqlClient.CodeFirst.CreateTable(typeof(Table.H_Test50C03));
Console.WriteLine("初始化freesql专用表成功!");
Console.WriteLine($"测试场景 Sqlserver 向表中插入{_count}条数据 50列 常规数据插入)");
Console.WriteLine($"适用于大量数据导入场景");
List<object> lstobj = new List<object>();
List<Table.H_Test50C02> lstobj2 = new List<Table.H_Test50C02>();
List<Table.H_Test50C03> lstobj3 = new List<Table.H_Test50C03>();
Random random = new Random();
//插入的参数值都随机产生 以免数据库执行相同SQL时会有缓存影响测试结果
for (int i = 0; i < _count; i++)
{
//hisql可以用实体类也可以用匿名类
lstobj.Add(new Table.H_Test50C01 {
Material=(900000+i).ToString(),
Batch=(30000000+i).ToString(),
TestNum1= random.Next(10,100),
TestNum2 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum3 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum4 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum5 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum6 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum7 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum8 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum9 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum10 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum11 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum12 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum13= random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum14= random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum15= random.Next(10, 100),
TestStr1 = $"hisql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr2 = $"hisql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr3 = $"hisql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr4 = $"hisql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr5 = $"hisql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr6 = $"hisql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr7 = $"hisql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr8 = $"hisql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr9 = $"hisql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr10 = $"hisql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr11 = $"hisql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr12 = $"hisql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr13 = $"hisql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr14 = $"hisql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr15 = $"hisql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestDec1 = i+ random.Next(1, 10000)/3,
TestDec2 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec3 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec4 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec5 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec6 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec7 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec8 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec9 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec10 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec11 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec12 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec13 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec14 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec15 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
Salary = 5000 + (i % 2000) + random.Next(10), Descript = $"hisql初始创建" });
//sqlsugar用匿句类报错用实体类
lstobj2.Add(new Table.H_Test50C02
{
Material = (900000 + i).ToString(),
Batch = (30000000 + i).ToString(),
TestNum1 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum2 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum3 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum4 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum5 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum6 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum7 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum8 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum9 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum10 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum11 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum12 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum13 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum14 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum15 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestStr1 = $"sqlsugar{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr2 = $"sqlsugar{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr3 = $"sqlsugar{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr4 = $"sqlsugar{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr5 = $"sqlsugar{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr6 = $"sqlsugar{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr7 = $"sqlsugar{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr8 = $"sqlsugar{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr9 = $"sqlsugar{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr10 = $"sqlsugar{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr11 = $"sqlsugar{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr12 = $"sqlsugar{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr13 = $"sqlsugar{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr14 = $"sqlsugar{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr15 = $"sqlsugar{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestDec1 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec2 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec3 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec4 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec5 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec6 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec7 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec8 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec9 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec10 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec11 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec12 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec13 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec14 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec15 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
Salary = 5000 + (i % 2000) + random.Next(10),
Descript = $"sqlsugar初始创建"
});
lstobj3.Add(new Table.H_Test50C03
{
Material = (900000 + i).ToString(),
Batch = (30000000 + i).ToString(),
TestNum1 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum2 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum3 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum4 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum5 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum6 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum7 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum8 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum9 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum10 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum11 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum12 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum13 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum14 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestNum15 = random.Next(10, 100),
TestStr1 = $"freesql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr2 = $"freesql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr3 = $"freesql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr4 = $"freesql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr5 = $"freesql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr6 = $"freesql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr7 = $"freesql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr8 = $"freesql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr9 = $"freesql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr10 = $"freesql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr11 = $"freesql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr12 = $"freesql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr13 = $"freesql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr14 = $"freesql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestStr15 = $"freesql{random.Next(1, 100).ToString()}",
TestDec1 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec2 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec3 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec4 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec5 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec6 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec7 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec8 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec9 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec10 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec11 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec12 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec13 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec14 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
TestDec15 = i + random.Next(1, 10000) / 3,
Salary = 5000 + (i % 2000) + random.Next(10),
Descript = $"freesql初始创建"
});
}
//删除测试表中的数据
sqlClient.TrunCate("H_Test50C01").ExecCommand();
sqlClient.TrunCate("H_Test50C02").ExecCommand();
sqlClient.TrunCate("H_Test50C03").ExecCommand();
Stopwatch sw = new Stopwatch();
#region freesql
sw.Reset();
Console.WriteLine("------------------------------");
Console.WriteLine("----------FreeSql 测试----------");
Console.WriteLine($"FreeSql 预热...{DateTime.Now.ToString("yyyy-MM-dd HH:mm:ss.fff")}");
var temp3 = freeClient.Queryable<Table.H_Test50C03>().Where(w => w.TestDec1 < 0).ToList();
Console.WriteLine($"FreeSql 正在插入数据\t{DateTime.Now.ToString("yyyy-MM-dd HH:mm:ss.fff")}");
sw.Start();
freeClient.Insert<Table.H_Test50C03>(lstobj3).ExecuteAffrows();
sw.Stop();
Console.WriteLine($"FreeSql 数据插入{_count}条 耗时{sw.Elapsed}秒");
sw.Reset();
#endregion
#region hisql
sw.Reset();
Console.WriteLine("------------------------------");
Console.WriteLine("----------HiSql 测试----------");
Console.WriteLine($"HiSql 预热...{DateTime.Now.ToString("yyyy-MM-dd HH:mm:ss.fff")}");
var temp1 = sqlClient.Query("H_Test50C01").Field("*").Take(1).Skip(1).ToDynamic();
Console.WriteLine($"HiSql 正在插入数据\t{DateTime.Now.ToString("yyyy-MM-dd HH:mm:ss.fff")}");
sw.Start();
sqlClient.Insert("H_Test50C01", lstobj).ExecCommand();
sw.Stop();
Console.WriteLine($"hisql 数据插入{_count}条 耗时{sw.Elapsed}秒");
sw.Reset();
#endregion
#region sqlsugar
sw.Reset();
Console.WriteLine("------------------------------");
Console.WriteLine("----------SqlSugar 测试----------");
Console.WriteLine($"SqlSugar 预热...{DateTime.Now.ToString("yyyy-MM-dd HH:mm:ss.fff")}");
var temp2 = sugarClient.Queryable<Table.H_Test50C03>("H_Test50C03").Where(w => w.TestDec1 < 1).ToList();
Console.WriteLine($"sqlsugar 正在插入数据\t{DateTime.Now.ToString("yyyy-MM-dd HH:mm:ss.fff")}");
sw.Start();
sugarClient.Insertable(lstobj2).AS("H_Test50C03").ExecuteCommand();
sw.Stop();
Console.WriteLine($"sqlsugar 数据插入{_count}条 耗时{sw.Elapsed}秒");
sw.Reset();
#endregion
}
测试结果
1W条数据10列以下字段bulkcopy插入测试
1W条数据50列字段bulkcopy插入测试
5W条数据10列以下字段bulkcpy插入测试
5W条数据50列字段bulkcopy插入测试
10W条数据10列以下字段Bulkcopy插入测试
10W条数据50列字段bulkcopy插入测试
20w条数据10列以下字段bulkcopy插入测试
20w条数据50列字段bulkcopy插入测试
50w条数据10列字段Bulkcopy插入测试
50w条数据50列字段BulkCopy插入测试
100W条10列以下字段bulkCopy插入测试
100W条数据50列字段bulkcopy插入测试
测试结果
总结
我想不用总结了 三个ORM不管是按常规插入和bulkcopy插入谁快认慢一目了然，不过我还是想贴上以下图
