豆包 VS Kimi VS DeepSeek：三种AI的绘图对决

最近AI话题引爆全网，豆包、Kimi和DeepSeek活跃在人们视野中，在各个领域大显神通。那么仅绘图方面而言，哪种AI模型会更胜一筹呢？请拭目以待！

指定任务：下“用Python绘制五星红旗”的相同指令以控制变量，生成的代码将在Python123上统一运行代码测试。

1.豆包

代码如下：

豆包版五星红旗


import turtle

# 设置画布和画笔
screen = turtle.Screen()
screen.bgcolor("red")
pen = turtle.Turtle()
pen.speed(10)
pen.hideturtle()

# 定义一些常量
width = 600
height = 400
big_star_radius = 60
small_star_radius = 20
# 计算五角星的顶点角度
angle = 144


# 定义绘制五角星的函数
def draw_star(t, radius, x, y):
    t.penup()
    t.goto(x, y)
    t.setheading(0)
    t.forward(radius)
    t.left(162)
    t.pendown()
    t.begin_fill()
    t.fillcolor("yellow")
    for _ in range(5):
        t.forward(2 * radius * 0.382)
        t.left(angle)
    t.end_fill()


# 绘制大五角星
big_star_x = -width / 2 + 100
big_star_y = height / 2 - 100
draw_star(pen, big_star_radius, big_star_x, big_star_y)

# 定义小五角星的位置和角度
small_stars_info = [
    # (x, y, angle)
    (-width / 2 + 250, height / 2 - 60, 30),
    (-width / 2 + 270, height / 2 - 120, 0),
    (-width / 2 + 270, height / 2 - 180, 350),
    (-width / 2 + 250, height / 2 - 240, 340)
]

# 绘制小五角星
for x, y, a in small_stars_info:
    pen.penup()
    pen.goto(x, y)
    pen.setheading(a)
    draw_star(pen, small_star_radius, x, y)

# 保持窗口打开
turtle.done()

豆包的表现有些差强人意，星星的边框颜色不对，其在红旗中的位置也偏零散，而且四颗小星星的角没有对准大星星。

向豆包反馈并再测试一次：

豆包版2.0

 import turtle

# 设置画布和画笔
screen = turtle.Screen()
screen.bgcolor("red")
pen = turtle.Turtle()
pen.speed(10)
pen.hideturtle()

# 定义国旗尺寸
width = 600
height = 400

# 定义五角星的绘制函数
def draw_star(t, radius, center_x, center_y):
    t.pencolor("yellow")
    t.fillcolor("yellow")
    t.penup()
    t.goto(center_x, center_y)
    t.setheading(0)
    t.forward(radius)
    t.left(162)
    t.pendown()
    t.begin_fill()
    for _ in range(5):
        t.forward(2 * radius * 0.382)
        t.left(144)
    t.end_fill()

# 绘制大五角星
big_star_radius = 0.15 * height
big_star_center_x = -0.3 * width
big_star_center_y = 0.3 * height
draw_star(pen, big_star_radius, big_star_center_x, big_star_center_y)

# 定义小五角星的位置、角度和半径
small_star_radius = 0.05 * height
small_star_positions = [
    (-0.1 * width, 0.45 * height, 30),
    (-0.05 * width, 0.35 * height, 0),
    (-0.05 * width, 0.2 * height, 350),
    (-0.1 * width, 0.1 * height, 340)
]

# 绘制小五角星
for x, y, angle in small_star_positions:
    pen.penup()
    pen.goto(x, y)
    pen.setheading(angle)
    draw_star(pen, small_star_radius, x, y)

# 保持窗口打开
turtle.done()

2.Kimi

代码如下：

Kimi版

 import turtle

# 初始化画布
screen = turtle.Screen()
screen.setup(width=600, height=400)  # 国旗宽高比为 3:2

# 设置画笔
star = turtle.Turtle()
star.speed(0)  # 设置画笔速度
star.hideturtle()  # 隐藏画笔箭头

# 绘制红色背景
def draw_background():
    star.penup()
    star.goto(-300, 200)  # 左上角
    star.pendown()
    star.color("#DC143C", "#DC143C")  # 使用深红色
    star.begin_fill()
    for _ in range(2):
        star.forward(600)  # 宽度
        star.right(90)
        star.forward(400)  # 高度
        star.right(90)
    star.end_fill()

# 绘制五角星
def draw_star(center_x, center_y, size, angle=0):
    star.penup()
    star.goto(center_x, center_y)
    star.setheading(angle)  # 设置五角星的方向
    star.forward(size)  # 移动到五角星的起始点
    star.left(162)  # 调整角度
    star.pendown()
    star.color("yellow", "yellow")  # 五角星颜色
    star.begin_fill()
    for _ in range(5):
        star.forward(size * 3)  # 五角星边长
        star.right(144)  # 内角
    star.end_fill()

# 绘制大五角星
def draw_big_star():
    draw_star(-220, 150, 30, angle=0)  # 大五角星位置和大小

# 绘制小五角星
def draw_small_stars():
    # 小五角星的位置和旋转角度
    small_stars = [
        (-150, 180, 10, 30),  # 第一颗小五角星
        (-130, 140, 10, 15),  # 第二颗
        (-130, 100, 10, -15),  # 第三颗
        (-150, 60, 10, -30)   # 第四颗
    ]
    for x, y, size, angle in small_stars:
        draw_star(x, y, size, angle)

# 主程序
if __name__ == "__main__":
    draw_background()  # 绘制红色背景
    draw_big_star()    # 绘制大五角星
    draw_small_stars() # 绘制四颗小五角星
    screen.mainloop()  # 保持窗口打开

Kimi的表现更是“天外有天，人外有人”，星星位置严重偏移先不提，本该是背底的红色只呈现了一条线，与标准形象大相径庭。

经过多次反复调试，得到代码如下：

Kimi版2.0

 import turtle

def draw_star(center, size, angle=0):
    turtle.penup()
    turtle.goto(center)
    turtle.setheading(angle)
    turtle.forward(size / 2)
    turtle.left(162)
    turtle.pendown()
    turtle.begin_fill()
    for _ in range(5):
        turtle.forward(size)
        turtle.right(144)
    turtle.end_fill()
    turtle.penup()

def draw_flag():
    # 设置画布
    turtle.setup(600, 400)
    turtle.bgcolor("red")
    turtle.speed(0)
    turtle.color("yellow")  # 设置星星颜色为黄色

    # 绘制大星星
    draw_star((-200, 100), 50)

    # 绘制小星星
    small_stars = [
        {"pos": (-150, 180), "angle": -15},
        {"pos": (-120, 140), "angle": -40},
        {"pos": (-120, 80), "angle": -70},
        {"pos": (-150, 20), "angle": -100}
    ]

    for star in small_stars:
        draw_star(star["pos"], 20, star["angle"])

    # 隐藏海龟
    turtle.hideturtle()
    turtle.done()

draw_flag()

3.DeepSeek

代码如下：

DeepSeek版

 
from turtle import *
"""绘制五角星,大小可变"""
def wujiaoxing(size):
    for i in range(6):
        forward(size)
        right(144)
 
"""绘制红色矩形"""
color("red","red")
begin_fill()
forward(192)
left(90)
forward(128)
left(90)
forward(192)
left(90)
forward(128)
end_fill()
"""绘制第一个大五角星"""
up()
goto(30,115)
down()
color("yellow","yellow")
begin_fill()
left(20)
wujiaoxing(30)
end_fill()
"""绘制第一个小五角星"""
up()
goto(55,110)
down()
color("yellow","yellow")
begin_fill()
right(10)
wujiaoxing(10)
end_fill()
"""绘制第二个小五角星"""
up()
goto(60,100)
down()
color("yellow","yellow")
begin_fill()
left(40)
wujiaoxing(10)
end_fill()
"""绘制第三个小五角星"""
up()
goto(70,87)
down()
color("yellow","yellow")
begin_fill()
right(30)
wujiaoxing(10)
end_fill()
"""绘制第四个小五角星"""
up()
goto(50,70)
down()
color("yellow","yellow")
begin_fill()
right(20)
wujiaoxing(10)
end_fill()
"""绘制文字"""
up()
goto(65,-50)
down()
color("black")
write("五星红旗",font=("微软雅黑",10))
 
hideturtle()
done()