JPEG最优压缩参数试验【光影魔术手VS Image Optimizer】
样本数量:100张(1MB~2.6MB)旅游照 | |||||||||||||||||
样本大小:157MB | 156.44 | ||||||||||||||||
样本尺寸:3M(2048*1536) | 3145728 | ||||||||||||||||
分辨率值:72dpi | |||||||||||||||||
位每像素:5.2083 | |||||||||||||||||
位深度值:24 | |||||||||||||||||
色彩标准:sRGB | |||||||||||||||||
统一要求:保留EXIF信息(删除可减小约20KB) | |||||||||||||||||
比对工具:Beyond Compare V3.3.4.14431 | |||||||||||||||||
比对方法:比对每种配置压缩产生的“重要差异像素”数量,越小越好! | |||||||||||||||||
容差阀值:使用PS另存为品质最佳12的JPEG格式,与原图对比,当容差为N时刚好不出现“重要差异像素”。 | |||||||||||||||||
Image OptimizerPro V5.10 6010 | |||||||||||||||||
JPEG质量 | 1% | 1% | 1% | 90% | 80% | 70% | 60% | 50% | 100% | 90% | 80% | ||||||
魔法压缩 | 0% | 50% | 100% | 0% | 0% | 0% | 0% | 0% | 50% | 50% | 50% | ||||||
从文件读取质量 | ✔ | ✔ | ✔ | ✘ | ✘ | ✘ | ✘ | ✘ | ✘ | ✘ | ✘ | ||||||
压缩后大小(MB) | 138.98 | 67.16 | 53.25 | 57.68 | 36.42 | 27.92 | 22.75 | 19.81 | 90.49 | 31.34 | 22.75 | ||||||
减小(百分比) | 11.16% | 57.07% | 65.96% | 63.13% | 76.72% | 82.15% | 85.46% | 87.34% | 42.16% | 79.97% | 85.46% | ||||||
CIMG0027:容差14 | 1,657 | 18,287 | 47,960 | 31,028 | 96,306 | 156,854 | 217,155 | 272,750 | 1,304 | 162,805 | 265,269 | ||||||
CIMG0024:容差15 | 73 | 675 | 1,463 | 1,150 | 2,972 | 4,939 | 7,526 | 10,360 | 90 | 4,644 | 8,605 | ||||||
CIMG9979:容差14 | 61 | 698 | 1,592 | 1,566 | 5,045 | 8,859 | 13,620 | 18,690 | 74 | 6,178 | 12,581 | ||||||
总差异像素 | 1,791 | 19,660 | 51,015 | 33,744 | 104,323 | 170,652 | 238,301 | 301,800 | 1,468 | 173,627 | 286,455 | ||||||
差异(百分比扩大45倍) | 0.8540% | 9.3746% | 24.3258% | 16.0904% | 49.7451% | 81.3732% | 113.6308% | 143.9095% | 0.7000% | 82.7918% | 136.5924% | ||||||
参考权值(越大越好) | 10.31% | 47.69% | 41.64% | 47.04% | 26.98% | 0.78% | -28.18% | -56.57% | 41.46% | -2.82% | -51.14% | ||||||
光影魔术手 V3.1.2.103 | |||||||||||||||||
JPEG质量 | 90% | 90% | 80% | 80% | 70% | 70% | 60% | 60% | 50% | 50% | 75% | 78% | 79% | 81% | 82% | 83% | |
高质量输出 | ✔ | ✘ | ✔ | ✘ | ✔ | ✘ | ✔ | ✘ | ✔ | ✘ | ✔ | ✔ | ✔ | ✔ | ✔ | ✔ | |
压缩后大小(MB) | 65.98 | 55.97 | 41.21 | 35.79 | 32.74 | 28.08 | 27.65 | 23.46 | 24.60 | 20.70 | 36.01 | 39.45 | 40.23 | 43.31 | 44.30 | 46.55 | |
减小(百分比) | 57.83% | 64.22% | 73.66% | 77.12% | 79.07% | 82.05% | 82.32% | 85.00% | 84.28% | 86.77% | 76.98% | 74.78% | 74.29% | 72.31% | 71.68% | 70.24% | |
CIMG0027:容差14 | 2,751 | 30,819 | 21,674 | 96,037 | 47,797 | 157,168 | 76,995 | 216,996 | 110,145 | 271,171 | 35,042 | 26,506 | 24,396 | 19,088 | 17,105 | 14,692 | |
CIMG0024:容差15 | 126 | 1,203 | 779 | 3,151 | 1,592 | 5,052 | 2,770 | 7,688 | 4,352 | 10,518 | 1,217 | 891 | 849 | 651 | 567 | 496 | |
CIMG9979:容差14 | 269 | 1,640 | 1,517 | 5,203 | 3,417 | 9,029 | 5,871 | 13,909 | 8,786 | 18,989 | 2,523 | 1,889 | 1,774 | 1,436 | 1,294 | 1,150 | |
总差异像素 | 3,146 | 33,662 | 23,970 | 104,391 | 52,806 | 171,249 | 85,636 | 238,593 | 123,283 | 300,678 | 38,782 | 29,286 | 27,019 | 21,175 | 18,966 | 16,338 | |
差异(百分比扩大45倍) | 1.5001% | 16.0513% | 11.4298% | 49.7775% | 25.1799% | 81.6579% | 40.8344% | 113.7700% | 58.7859% | 143.3744% | 18.4927% | 13.9647% | 12.8837% | 10.0970% | 9.0437% | 7.7906% | |
参考权值(越大越好) | 56.32% | 48.17% | 62.23% | 27.35% | 53.89% | 0.39% | 41.49% | -28.77% | 25.49% | -56.61% | 58.49% | 60.82% | 61.40% | 62.22% | 62.64% | 62.45% | |
如果相同配置压缩同一组照片,压缩出来的照片MD5不一样,即存在压缩噪点。经过测试,不会出现这种情况。比对不同软件压缩质量时,不用考虑压缩噪点问题。 | |||||||||||||||||
结论:使用光影魔术手的80~85%高质量输出的压缩配置是当前最优选择。 |
|||||||||||||||||
By:AsionTang | |||||||||||||||||
DT:2013年6月16日 21:31:36 |
作者:Asion Tang
凡是没有注明[转载]的文章,本Blog发表的文章版权归作者所有,欢迎转载,但未经作者同意必须保留此段声明,且在文章页面明显位置给出原文连接,否则保留追究法律责任的权利。