X-develop发布的几款IDE的比较，挺有意思～

下面是Omnicore公司为宣传他们的IDE产品X-develop而做的一个几款IDE比较的表格，从中我们可以看出很多有趣的东西来。

    
            

            
            
            X-develop
            VS.net
            VS.net + Resharper
            IDEA
            Eclipse
        

            Language Support
        

            Java 1.4
            Yes
            No
            No
            Yes
            Yes
        

            Java 5.0
            Yes
            No
            No
            Yes
            Yes
        

            JSP
            Yes
            No
            No
            Yes
            No2
        

            C# 1.0
            Yes
            Yes
            Yes
            No
            No
        

            C# 2.0
            Yes
            Not yet1
            Not yet1
            No
            No
        

            J# 1.0
            Yes
            Yes
            Yes3
            No
            No
        

            J# 2.0
            Yes
            Not yet1
            Not yet1,3
            No
            No
        

            Visual Basic .NET
            Yes
            Yes
            Yes3
            No
            No
        

            Platform Support
        

            Windows
            Yes
            Yes
            Yes
            Yes
            Yes
        

            Linux
            Yes
            No
            No
            Yes
            Yes
        

            Mac OS X
            Yes
            No
            No
            Yes
            Yes
        

            Java
            Yes
            No
            No
            Yes
            Yes
        

            Microsoft .NET
            Yes
            Yes
            Yes
            No
            No
        

            Mono
            Yes
            No
            No
            No
            No
        

            Code analysis & Code editor
        

            Multi-language core engine
            Yes
            No
            No
            No
            No
        

            On-the-fly error checking
            Yes
            Only for VB.net
            Only for C#, VB.net3
            Only for Java, JSP
            Only for Java
        

            Project-wide on-the-fly checking / incremental compilation
            Yes
            Only for VB.net
            Only for VB.net3
            No
            Only for Java
        

            Checking speed
            Fast
            Medium
            Poor
            Poor
            Medium
        

            Refactoring
            Yes
            Not yet1
            Only for C#
            Yes
            Yes
        

            Cross-language refactoring
            Yes
            No
            No
            No
            No
        

            Organize imports/usings
            Yes
            No
            Only for C#
            Yes
            Yes
        

            Code generation
            Yes
            No
            Only for C#
            Yes
            Yes
        

            Goto class/symbol by name
            Yes
            Not yet1
            Only for C#
            Yes
            Yes
        

            Find usages
            Yes
            Not yet1
            Only for C#
            Yes
            Yes
        

            Go to overriding/overridden method
            Yes
            No
            Only for C#
            Yes
            Yes
        

            Version control support
        

            Unified version control system support
            Yes
            No
            No
            No
            No
        

            CVS support
            Yes
            No2
            No2
            Yes
            Yes
        

            Bitkeeper support
            Yes
            No2
            No2
            No
            No
        

            Perforce support
            Yes
            No2
            No2
            Yes
            No
        

            Subversion support
            Yes
            No2
            No2
            Yes1
            No2
        

            Visual SourceSafe support
            Yes
            Yes
            Yes3
            Yes
            No2
        

            On-the-fly diff display
            Yes
            No
            No
            Yes
            Yes
        

            On-the-fly annotation view
            Yes
            No
            No
            No
            No
        

            Debugging
        

            Java debugger with Step back
            Yes
            No
            No
            No
            No
        

            Conventional .NET debugger
            Yes
            Yes
            Yes3
            No
            No
        

            JSP debugging
            Yes
            No
            No
            Yes
            No2
        

            Experimental Mono debugger
            Yes
            No
            No
            No
            No
        

            GUI designer
        

            Integrated GUI designer
            Yes
            Yes
            Yes3
            Yes
            Yes
        

            AWT
            Yes
            No
            No
            Yes
            No
        

            Swing
            Yes
            No
            No
            Yes
            Yes
        

            Windows Forms
            Yes
            Yes
            Yes3
            No
            No
        

            GTK#
            Yes
            No
            No
            No
            No
        

            Unit testing
        

            JUnit support
            Yes
            No
            No
            Yes
            Yes
        

            NUnit support
            Yes
            No
            Not yet1
            No
            No
        

            Teamsystem support
            Yes
            Not yet1
            Not yet1
            No
            No
        

	X-develop	VS.net	VS.net + Resharper	IDEA	Eclipse
Language Support
Java 1.4	Yes	No	No	Yes	Yes
Java 5.0	Yes	No	No	Yes	Yes
JSP	Yes	No	No	Yes	No²
C# 1.0	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No
C# 2.0	Yes	Not yet¹	Not yet¹	No	No
J# 1.0	Yes	Yes	Yes³	No	No
J# 2.0	Yes	Not yet¹	Not yet^1,3	No	No
Visual Basic .NET	Yes	Yes	Yes³	No	No
Platform Support
Windows	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
Linux	Yes	No	No	Yes	Yes
Mac OS X	Yes	No	No	Yes	Yes
Java	Yes	No	No	Yes	Yes
Microsoft .NET	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No
Mono	Yes	No	No	No	No
Code analysis & Code editor
Multi-language core engine	Yes	No	No	No	No
On-the-fly error checking	Yes	Only for VB.net	Only for C#, VB.net³	Only for Java, JSP	Only for Java
Project-wide on-the-fly checking / incremental compilation	Yes	Only for VB.net	Only for VB.net³	No	Only for Java
Checking speed	Fast	Medium	Poor	Poor	Medium
Refactoring	Yes	Not yet¹	Only for C#	Yes	Yes
Cross-language refactoring	Yes	No	No	No	No
Organize imports/usings	Yes	No	Only for C#	Yes	Yes
Code generation	Yes	No	Only for C#	Yes	Yes
Goto class/symbol by name	Yes	Not yet¹	Only for C#	Yes	Yes
Find usages	Yes	Not yet¹	Only for C#	Yes	Yes
Go to overriding/overridden method	Yes	No	Only for C#	Yes	Yes
Version control support
Unified version control system support	Yes	No	No	No	No
CVS support	Yes	No²	No²	Yes	Yes
Bitkeeper support	Yes	No²	No²	No	No
Perforce support	Yes	No²	No²	Yes	No
Subversion support	Yes	No²	No²	Yes¹	No²
Visual SourceSafe support	Yes	Yes	Yes³	Yes	No²
On-the-fly diff display	Yes	No	No	Yes	Yes
On-the-fly annotation view	Yes	No	No	No	No
Debugging
Java debugger with Step back	Yes	No	No	No	No
Conventional .NET debugger	Yes	Yes	Yes³	No	No
JSP debugging	Yes	No	No	Yes	No²
Experimental Mono debugger	Yes	No	No	No	No
GUI designer
Integrated GUI designer	Yes	Yes	Yes³	Yes	Yes
AWT	Yes	No	No	Yes	No
Swing	Yes	No	No	Yes	Yes
Windows Forms	Yes	Yes	Yes³	No	No
GTK#	Yes	No	No	No	No
Unit testing
JUnit support	Yes	No	No	Yes	Yes
NUnit support	Yes	No	Not yet¹	No	No
Teamsystem support	Yes	Not yet¹	Not yet¹	No	No

Compared versions: X-develop 1.2, VS.NET 2003/2005¹, Resharper 1.5, IDEA 5.0, Eclipse 3.1

¹ available in a beta/preview version
² supported by third-party plugin
³ does not add anything to VS.net functionality

首先，所有的功能在X-develop一列中的支持结果都是Yes。这也算是理所当然的事情，人家怎么可能搬起石头砸自己的脚～但是，我总是觉得假假的，呵呵。X-develop主要标榜的是自己的多语言支持性和多平台支持性，所以把Language Support和Platform Support放在了最前面，而且极度突出了自己在这两方面的优势。看着Eclipse一列那么多的No，我忍不住笑了出来，虽然在表格最后面的附注里面有说supported by third-party plugin，但这多少有点儿愚民的感觉。
在Code analysis & Code editor一组中，吸引我的是Checking speed，Eclipse 是Medium，其他VS.NET + Resharper和IDEA都被无情的打上了Poor。Version control support是最搞笑的一组，X-develop看上去有巨大的优势，但是我很怀疑它所额外支持的东西是否比较有用。GUI designer和Unit testing也没有什么出奇的地方，X-develop支持那么多是因为它支持多语言，这是很正常的，不支持才不正常。
最让我眼前一亮的是Debugging中的Java debugger with Step back！这个可真的是个好东西，而且我也从来没在其他IDE中发现过。它强大的地方在于，在debug的时候可以让程序倒退着运行，这对观察程序行为，调试很复杂或tricky的bug是很有用的。

看过之后总体感觉下来，X-develop面向的用户是没有深入使用其他主流IDE的开发人员。我个人是不会因为这些比较而改变我的IDE使用习惯，但是在debug的时候，如果真的有很难调试的bug，我也许会到X-develop下面用Step back试试。另外再提一下，X-develop是要钱的，而且我还没找到crak... :(

posted on 2006-04-17 17:53 Allen Young 阅读(965) 评论(0) 编辑收藏举报